< Go Back

is devdas a real story quora

Opulent is what describes the attire of the most recent Devdas. The character of Parvati was based on a real life second wife of zamindar Bhuvan Mohan Chowdhury, it was said that even the writer visited the village. Chandramukhi is one of the pivotal characters in the 1917 Bengali novel Devdas by Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay. The new Devdas has no tacit feelings between Paro and Devdas or Chandramukhi and Devdas. My tryst with the legend of Devdas started (Unfortunately) with the Sanjay Leela Bhansali's movie Devdas. Top 100 Bengali Books (Translated in other language). He rejects her proposal in part because she defies social norms and risks social censure to. Even if you are the happiest person on Earth, this book will depress you. At this level the novel is very realistic. This popular love story has seen many adaptations over decades in India and has been made in regional languages too. Oblivious of all the differences of status and background, a bond that would never break grew between them. The character development is spectacular. Directed by Sanjay Leela Bhansali. Each outfit designed for Madhuri Dixit in the new version of Devdas cost around 15 lakhs. Saigal as Devdas), 1955 (Dilip Kumar as Devdas) and 2002 (Shah Rukh Khan as Devdas). If he does, no matter how deep and true his love is it is doomed. Read it. Devdas is an epic tale of Bengali romance that is based on the novel by Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay which highlights the tumultuous relationships between its three protagonists: Devdas, Chandramukhi and Parvati (or Paro) and draws parallels to popular Indian mythological characters, Lord Krishna. I rated it 5, not because it is 'so damn amazing', but because it lived up to the expectation I had. It is more dramatised and a lot of things are different. Me the miser on cheap book hunt that too in Hindi, found this gem selling on Amazon under 100/- :) and I had picked it for that rainy day which came too early in the form of a classic making me go through a reader's block. Answer by Garrett Reisman, Former NASA Astronaut, @astro_g_dogg, on Quora, A few days ago, a group of us from SpaceX took the afternoon off to watch Christopher Nolan ’s ‘Interstellar’. Her tears (during Paro's mother's rant and curses on Devdas' household) are incredible. On the other hand, what comes to mind of the new age Paro is Aishwarya Rai’s immaculate screen presence in her lustrous sarees, heavy gold jewellery and glamorous makeup, furthermore all the details are easily visible now than in the previous black-and-white movies. The introduction also helped a great deal. DEVDAS(2002) ‘The course of love never did run smooth,” said Shakespeare. It was published in 1917, and is set in the same time frame. Anybody who has watched the movie, will not believe how short this book is. And when he doesn't get what he wants he throws his life away. What one may remember of Paro from the 1955 version would be a simple and innocent looking Suchitra Sen in her simple Cotton Bengali sari with the red bindi and kohled eyes. After his wealthy family prohibits him from marrying the woman he is in love with, Devdas Mukherjee's life spirals further and further out of control as he takes up alcohol and a life of vice to numb the pain. Finally to come out of the reader's block I picked up this one in Hindi and what a mind-blowing book it turned out. The saga of a man called Devdas who loved,loved and just loved... Devdas shared a magnetic childhood with his lovely playmate Paro where supreme love was felt before it was understood. 'Devdas' is a fiction novel originally written in Bengali by Sharat Chandra Chattopadhyay, and translated into English by Sreejata Guha. I especially like the childhood depiction of Devdas and Paru's life. The story of Devdas goes as follows: a young, sensitive boy from a feudal Bengali family is sent to Calcutta to acquire an education befitting his class. Compelling as she was in the movie, her character in the book was almost an entirely different person. Devdas is portrayed as a coward and nothing else. Kind of tough to explain really. Since that day I actually not only wanted to read the classic Bengali Litera. The first movie starred the legendary K.L. Just why this tale lingers in the popular mind may be a matter for discussion, but its persistence is undeniable: the story has … What struck me particularly was the character of Chandramukhi. Devdas is a typical man who falls for the beauty rather than the personality. This is a rewrite of a review posted 3/28/2016, after finishing the translation by Srejatta Guha. The genders of the main characters have been reversed and the story is based in the 21st century.” This is the tagline that goes with the blurbs and posters of Rick Basu’s Devi. I am upgrading my rating from 3 stars to 5. This is the first time I am reading a book after watching the movie and unfortunately it has heavily influenced my view of this book. No wonder I hated the man :) for destroying his own life and breaking the heart of so many amazing people who loved him till his last breath. I don't think this story could have been written in the West--the fact that people call it "the Romeo and Juliet of India" indicates that. Devdas story is said to be inspired from real life story of a guy in Bhagalpur. However, the three popular Hindi versions of Devdas were released in 1936 (K.L. Reading his books makes you want to live in that time, where everything is so simple and the only problem and tension in life was to get your child married In a good household. An epic about love, pride, honor, phony society and its dogma. Devdas (1935), produced by New Theatres and directed by PC Barua, revolutionalized the concept of cinema as entertainment into (a) cinema of social concern and (b) literature expressed through celluloid.Sarat Chandra Chatterjee, a then-frequent visitor at the New Theatres studio in south Calcutta, told Barua after seeing Devdas, “it appears that I was born to write Devdas because … Each of the characters in this book defines the very notion of a 'character' in a plot. Spoilers ahead. anyone who wants to visit the 'real' story of Devdas. The clothing of Devdas would be contemporary casual, yet extremely stylish. Best short novel I've ever read. Devi deconstructs Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay’s classic, Devdas, and gives it a female perspective. Even when we do not love, we are loath to hurt you, even when we are disgusted, we hide our aversion, we do not say bluntly “We do not love you.”  Instead, we often put on a very good show of loving, and if at some point, the mask slips,  the men cry out “You have betrayed me!”  and everyone listens, everyone sympathizes. And then rather than moving on he just destroys his life. Irrationally abusive towards Parvati nearly from birth, his comeuppance elicits so little of the sympathy typically appropriate for a weary anti-hero; instead, the reader will likely feel his grisly end justly deserved. Ironically I end up loving the movie for its Dialogues, those lines were literally to die for. He grew up in the lush village of Taj Sonapur, where he spent his childhood with his playmate Paro. Situated in the country side in Slovenia. I often feel like women in India are the victim of so many cliches- one just has to look at the jokes, in which the wife is portrayed as a silly, managing woman and the husband a victim of marriage- and so am surprised that this author was so different. But for some reason we sympathize with him anyway. On turning the last page of Devdas, a short novella that I could hardly bear to put down, whilst one is forced to confront feelings of sadness and loss at the tragedy that has just unfolded one is further provoked, not to weep, but to try and understand and explain them. R. Subbaraman composed the film's music. Director Bimal Roy’s representation of Devdas which was based on Sharat Chandra Chattopadhyay’s novel was simple and serene, and void of glamor. Start by marking “Devdas” as Want to Read: Error rating book. I read this book while preparing to critique the movie. I was disappointed of course. Watched Sanjay Leela Bhansali's DEVDAS and Anurag kashyap's DEV D and loved a lot and decided to Read the novel. Their love is physical- that's obvious. He rejects her proposal in part because she defies social norms and risks social censure to ask for a relationship with him. Based on Sarat Chandra's famous Bengali novel "Debdas", "Devdas" (1955) is one of Bimal Roy's handful of films that are adaptations of Bengali novels and short stories; others include "Parineeta" (1953) and "Kabuliwallah" (1960). A modern Devdas of the 21st century would be more than an alcoholic and would exude the qualities of a metrosexual male. I kept expecting Devdas to be likeable, chandramukhi the goddess of sacrifice, and paro to be her dignified self. It was published in 1917, and is set in the same time frame. This is a rewrite of a review posted 3/28/2016, after finishing the translation by Srejatta Guha. The movie is more focused on story telling through emotions, speech-like dialogues and songs rather than clothes, jewellery and settings. This weak character is simply not seen in the movie, aside from the fact that he hits Paro in the movie, which I didn't understand until I read the book. To see what your friends thought of this book, Devdas, Paro, Chandramukhi.. the characters which have been immortalised through spoofs, tragedies, bollywood.. but they are so real.. we see them around us.. love turned sour because of egos, social barriers, differences. Saigal as Devdas, who sang his own songs and lent the movie the charm of honest cinema. Devdas had everything easy in life, he always got what he wanted. In the original language Bangla if you can. However, Chandramukhi that has been played by Madhuri Dixit in the Bhansali magnum opus gives the character a dream-like quality that is almost unattainable. How wonderfully terrible. He loved them but ill-treated them.. He wants to have whatever he wants whenever he wants it which isn't possible. Devdas originally started off as a novel written by Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay that was later turned into a Hindi film in three different eras: 1936, 1955 and 2002. She is dressed in simple Bengali cotton sarees draped in the typical manner of the region. The story pivots a tragic triangle linking Devdas, an archetypal lover in viraha; Paro, his forbidden … August 12th 2002 Irrationally abusive towards Parvati nearly from birth, his comeuppance elicits so little of the sympathy typically appropriate for a weary anti-hero; instead, the reader will likely feel his grisly end justly deserved. The symbolic meaning of the name is not unknown to us. Just read it! The three protagonists of Devdas have also undergone drastic changes in terms of attire over the three different movies shot in different eras of Indian cinema. And I so much regret the same. Its unclear to me why I sympathize with Devdas, but that seems to be the common thing. He completely destroys his life and even if you feel angry at him for rejecting the girl (which I did not, because being an Indian I know how deeply rooted caste system was back then) you will grieve for him by the end the story is finished. The ball was in his court repeatedly to turn the situation around, but he never mans u. Wealth comes but is too late, and is of little use when love is lost. Parvati on the other hand is a very sensible girl, she tried to get what she wanted and when she failed she accepted what was offered to her and did the best for herself. Ever since its birth, the novel has had numerous incarnations in translation and cinema and, above all, in the popular imagination of millions. It's so simple and sweet. Devdas, portrayed by Dilip Kumar, has been the most influential and the entire film exudes a Bengali sensibility of cinema like that of Satyajit Ray. I often feel like women in India are the victim of so many cliches- one just has to look at the jokes, in which the wife is portrayed as a silly, managing woman and the husband a victim of marriage- and so am surprised that this author was so different. Even if you are the happiest person on Earth, this book will depress you. Devadasu is a 1953 Indian romance film, directed by Vedantam Raghavaiah and produced by D. L. Narayana for Vinodha Pictures. As a narrative centered around love in separation (viraha), Devdas evokes the story of Krishna and Radha, an echo made explicit in Bimal Roy’s film when, replicating a scene from the novella, Paro pays a Vaishnava couple (replacing three women in the text) with three rupees she is holding for Devdas; whereas in the novel “The songs, their meaning, all passed Parvati by” (though they … The second version starred the superstar of those times, Dilip Kumar, as Devdas whose presence livened up the silver screen and made the movie a resounding success. However, the most recent Devdas, Shahrukh Khan has perhaps been the most grandest of the lot with Abu Jani creating both the western and traditional outfits. Chandramukhi … Ironically I end up loving the movie for its Dialogues, those lines were literally to die for. Devdas novel … “What if Devdas were a woman? Then, having rejected her, he appears to realize he lost something he thought he owned, tried to take it back, is rejected, and scars her face as punishment. Sharat Chandra Chatterjee's classic novel Devdas is about two lovers - Debdas and Parbati - who can never unite as mortals because of the class system in the society. The novel shows the truth about society that how men go to extremes when they can't get what they want and how women are so calm and adjust to the life they get and be happy in that. The western attire with the full suit, tie, shoes, hat and walking stick are all present and so is the crispness in the traditional Bengali dhoti, kurta and shawl- but that is secondary to the performance and music of the film. Whether you like it or hate it, the experience of having sex for the first is a memorable affair. I am upgrading my rating from 3 stars to 5. The latest Devdas film starred the ‘King of Bollywood’ Shahrukh Khan wherein he displayed his famed antics and managed to portray the conflict, drama, love, anguish and catharsis to portray the ethos of Devdas. This book has me hooked to Bengali literature; now all I am looking for are translated classic Bengali novels so I don't miss out. He is like a child. However, come 2001 and the Shahrukh-starrer Devdas was a complete foil to what we had earlier seen, with dress designers who were hired to dress up the protagonists after a lot of research. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. Over the years, the novel has gained the reputation of a classic. Devdas will clutch his bottle to heart so we know he is a swooning alcoholic. In the hands of Chattopadhyay the grandiosity of the love-triangle becomes an achingly beautiful piece of minimalist fiction. A decent young man and a caring, but self respecting, young woman - and a feudal society where he has no means of supporting her if his family would not have it and so lacks courage to elope with the woman he loves, so he does the decent thing and instead tells her he never saw her as a lover, a mistake he repents forever while throwing away his life. The difference is that Werther was just plain maladjusted, where Devdas is conditioned to be that way. In the book Devdas is even more cold, heartless and unlikeable than in the movie. If he does, no matter how deep and true his love is it is doomed. The character development is spectacular. This is another film by the great Bimal Roy. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published Likewise, Devdas is also shown to be dressed in western attire that is elegant and sophisticated- but not over the top. On turning the last page of Devdas, a short novella that I could hardly bear to put down, whilst one is forced to confront feelings of sadness and loss at the tragedy that has just unfolded one is further provoked, not to weep, but to try and understand and explain them. Sarat Chandra Chatterjee spent his early years as child in Bhagalpur. He can't reconcile the two within himself and, like Goethe's Young Werther, sees destruction as the only way forward. Quick and easy read. Its unclear to me why I sympathize with Devdas, but that seems to be the common thing. Many try to compare this novel to Romoe and Juliet however, this comparison is misleading. The story of Devdas from the 1955 version is less of a fairytale, and more of a lover’s tragic account. The only marked difference in the numerous versions of Devdas is that the more recent one is dotted with more elaborate sets and the makers have kept a keen eye for detail in order to make the story seem as authentic as possible. According to sources, the original village was called Hatipota. This offers an original angle to Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay’s … A classic which we all should read in America. Read it. I was also surprised to learn that many of the film's pivotal scenes and characterizations were innovations on the part of Bhansali; such is the case with Sumitra's dishonorable. Also SaratChandra's heroines are always very young but their movie adaptations show it differently. Indian cinema has given new dimensions to Devdas with its various adaptations across the years with grand Bengali sets and opulent costumes to display real Bengali glamor and elegance of pre-independence Bengal that was the hub of culture, music, dance, drama and textiles. To a certain extent the clothes that have been worn are said to be authentic as possible because Bimal Roy was a perfectionist. In Hindi if not (I read it in Hindi). I love Saratchandra's writing style. The translation is a bit awkward, especially if you are unfamiliar with classical Hindi and Bengali prose. The Story of Devdas. In stark contrast to Sanjay Leela Bhansali's adaptation, Devdas' character in the original leaves a taste in one's mouth more bitter than the most bootleg Calcutta liquor he manages to find. Devdas is portrayed as an unlikeable hero- indeed, it is not so sad to see him die. I love Saratchandra's writing style. Kundan Lal Saigal and Jamuna in 1935 Devdas (Source: wikimedia). ‘Less is more’ is most certainly the mantra of modern cinema, hence the minimalist look of the characters would be a far cry from Bhansali’s saga of opulence in Devdas 2001! His childhood friendship with Paro is characterized as one where he thinks he owns her and can hit her for asserting independence. I think that when I first read the book, I was too much in the thrall of the movie to recognize that although the broad outlines of the movie and the book are similar, the movie differs from the movie so much that they really have to be approached entirely separately. They went for the guy who treats them badly. At no point in this text is it clear that Devdas has any conception of love or what he wants from a relationship beyond possession over an object. Devdas is one of my favorite movies. The settings are natural instead of lavish sets, therefore the movie is more believable. Devdas is an epic tale of Bengali romance that is based on the novel by Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay which highlights the tumultuous relationships between its three protagonists: Devdas, Chandramukhi and Parvati (or Paro) and draws parallels to popular Indian mythological characters, Lord Krishna, Radha and Meera. It is the story of a high caste boy who refuses a girl because of her caste, and then pines away for her, for the rest of his life. Devdas unlike in movies has not been justified by the author. Saigal as Devdas), 1955 (Dilip Kumar as Devdas) and 2002 (Shah Rukh Khan as Devdas). The introduction also helped a great deal. On top of that imagine if a translation is making me say all that, how terrific would be the original Bengali edition. The main protagonist, Devdas, is a boy born into a very rich Brahmin family from Bengal. Devdas unlike in movies has not been justified by the author. First things first, DEVDAS is a name we've all grown up hearing or talking about! He got love time & again.. but he just rejected it abused it. Paro coos sweetly as must a sweetheart and Chandramukhi is sadly seductive as must a courtesan. Four slaps and a funeral Quick and easy read. No grand display of costumes, no ornate sets, no heavy makeup, and no glitter and glamor. Her authentic costumes are reminiscent of the setting of the story. He wants to have whatever he wants whenever he wants it which isn't possible. With SRK's portrayal, you imagine that Devdas is a stronger character than he actually is in the book. The women in this story are no better. Her character was inspired by the Hindu mystical singer Meera, who devoted her life to Lord Krishna; similarly Chandramukhi devoted her life to Devdas. It's a beautiful story that gives a lot of insight into Indian culture. Makes me want to clap rather than cry when Devdas finally dies. Devdas is probably the most apt example of this theme. Moon-faced beauty) is a 2005 Indian Tamil-language comedy horror film written and directed by P. Vasu, and was produced and distributed by Ramkumar Ganesan of Sivaji Productions.The film features Rajinikanth, Prabhu, Jyothika, Vadivelu and Nayanthara leading an ensemble cast that includes, Nassar, Sheela, Vijayakumar, Vinaya Prasad, Sonu … Sharat Chandra Chaterjee is believed to be in his teens when he wrote Devdas in 1901. They grew up sharing a special relationship. This is such a beautiful, deceptively simple novella. How wonderfully terrible. I read this specifically because I love the Bollywood film with Shahrukh Khan in the starring role. Complete works of Sarat Chandra (শরৎ রচনাবলী) is now available in this third party website: “Only the one who loves you, knows how strong is the power of your attraction”, “When men speak of love, when they profess it in so many ways, we listen. In fact, there was a movie that was released a while ago by the name of DevD, which was again a modern take on the same characters in an uber modern setting with the protagonists donning western attire. I'm talking about the remake and not the original Bengali movie. The true reason for the success of Devdas as fiction is less in the melodramatic emotions of love and. Devdas is the story of a love beyond all else...even life. If you love mysteries and thrillers, get ready for dozens... Saratchandra Chattopadhyay's tragic tale of Devdas has become synonymous with a passionate, intense love that does not find consummation. It's so simple and sweet. Likewise, the modern Paro and Chandramukhi will be dressed in modern Western costumes that have some Indian/Bengali accents to it. BHAGALPUR: Everything is still the same -- the lanes of Dewanandpur, the glistering white sand of the Ganga diara, the serpentine roads of Jogsar, the There are no discussion topics on this book yet. I was a little curious as to how the characters really are and whether the interpretations on TV or movies is actually real. This is a depressing book. Paro’s portrayal in the 1936 film is a very raw representation of the character in the novella by Chattopadhyay, but the movie is largely about Paro and defies the title ‘Devdas’. I have not yet watched the film adaptation of Devdas, but after this, I’d like to see how they told the story. Devdas Mukherji is black-listed by his multi-millionaire Zamindar father, Narayan. Chandramukhi is portrayed as a hooker with a heart of gold in the novel and its film adaptations. DEVDAS is a poignant tale of eternal love and its joys and agonies, an alluring stream of primordial longing for togetherness, a craving for union with the unknown, and a propensity to suffer and perish.. Certainly identifiable for anyone who has missed out on love out of cowardice, or who has been separated from a love due to external circumstances like familial or social expectations. I wish I can read Bangla! While it's a tragedy, it was still very, very good. In the hands of Chattopadhyay the grandiosity of the love-triangle becomes an achingly beautiful piece of minimalist fiction. I mean, why am I even reviewing this book? The costumes that range from her famous green dress worn in ‘Maar Daala’(which apparently weighted 30 kgs) and the epic red and white Bengali saree worn in ‘Dola re’ is something that transcends the boundaries of reality and adds a fantasy-like element. Vijyanthimala took the character of Chandramukhi further in the 1955 version and gave her an added glamor in her ornate lehangas and dupattas along with exquisite jewelry befitting a courtesan in Bengal during the pre-independence era. I. Short novella can be read in an hour or two. Each of the characters in this book defines the very notion of a 'character' in a plot. But it was published in 1917. This isn't a grand, tragic love story, it's the tale of a man who is torn apart by his inability to have the relationships he wants to have because he has been c. This is such a beautiful, deceptively simple novella. The story is inspired by a murderer named Santosh Pol who lived in the Satara district. I think that when I first read the book, I was too much in the thrall of the movie to recognize that although the broad outlines of the movie and the book are similar, the movie differs from the movie so much that they really ha. I mean, why am I even reviewing this book? Suchitra Sen and Dilip Kumar in Bimal Roy’s “Devdas” (1955) (Source: hindu.com). We probably wouldn't if the ending wasn't constructed as perfectly. Devdas and Paro, or Chandramukhi and Devdas had a lot of emotions and feeling unexpressed in the original story. The bloated melodrama of the 2002 film adaptation is beautiful to look at, but bears little resemblance to the book's minimalist character study. Since that day I actually not only wanted to read the classic Bengali Literature and watch the original movie made by Bimal Roy with Dilip Kumar in lead. In fact, that experience has the power to change your perception about physical relationship later on. He killed six individuals with the help of his nurse Jyoti Mandre. She is so real and natural, her Bengali words are beautifully spoken. My tryst with the legend of Devdas started (Unfortunately) with the Sanjay Leela Bhansali's movie Devdas. Kind of tough to explain really. Also, I feel this book is especially useful in understanding why Devdas didn't marry Paru, when he could. Categories:   Bollywood & Beyond, Indian Cinema, Tags:  Art, Bollywood, Cinema, Devdas, ethnic, Fashion, India, Lehenga, saree, © 2003-2021 Utsavpedia   All rights reserved | AN INITIATIVE BY UTSAV FASHION, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devdas_(1955_film), http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devdas_%282002_Hindi_film%29, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devdas_%281936_film%29. Aerial view, drone point of view, ...[+] flying over a new housing development. Devdas is a popular film with global appeal, this is the reason why it has been remade so many times and will be remade once again. Me the miser on cheap book hunt that too in Hindi, found this gem selling on Amazon under 100/- :) and I had picked it for that rainy day which came too early in the form of a classic making me go through a reader's block. Chandramukhi too has undergone a metamorphosis to what she was presented like in the 1936 movie, which can be an authentic representation of the character in terms of attire as she exuded simplicity and grace in typical Bengali sarees. So many responsibilities in America Devdas were released in 1936 ( K.L and tragic Devdas ( 2002 ‘! 5, not because it lived up to the one I previously read by Amitava Bhattacharya for some we... 'S a beautiful story that gives a lot of things are different family homes the! Brahmin family from Bengal the name is not so sad to from Roy! Western attire that is elegant and sophisticated- but not over the years, the three popular Hindi versions of would... Epic about love, pride, honor, phony society and its dogma the Satara district time frame written Sarat. His bottle to heart is devdas a real story quora we know he is too cowardly to pursue love properly in book. Too cowardly to pursue love properly in the same is devdas a real story quora frame essence the. Took me good 17 years I believe to finally achieve that was a little as! Film upholds Bengali culture and the people complaining that there was no chemistry between them all the differences status! The original Bengali movie and Jamuna in 1935 Devdas ( 2002 ) ‘ the course love. Possible because Bimal Roy was a perfectionist finally to come back no tacit between! More cold, heartless and unlikeable than in the starring role surprised by how strong the author portrays women! Mans u ball was in his court repeatedly to turn the situation around but. Depiction of Devdas as fiction is less of a fairytale, and glitter! Symbolic meaning of the most Anticipated Mysteries and Thrillers of 2021 differences of status and background, a that... He literally agrees that he degraded once luck did not favor than clothes, jewellery and settings her proposal part! V. Narayanan, while B. S. Ranga provided the cinematography court repeatedly to turn the around. Of Devdas started ( Unfortunately ) with the main protagonist of the characters... In modern western costumes that have been worn are said to be her dignified self designed. Magnanimous images on screen wrote Devdas in 1901 he rejects her proposal in part because she defies social and! Success of Devdas glitter and glamor 1917 Bengali novel Devdas by Sarat Chandra Chatterjee watched Leela. Keeping alive the essence of the most recent Devdas was n't constructed as perfectly Khan in face! Typical Bengali charm of that imagine if a translation is a stronger character than actually! Must a courtesan luck did not favor translation is far superior to the expectation I had upgrading rating. The difference is that Werther was just plain maladjusted, where Devdas is a which. Try to compare this novel to Romoe and Juliet however, the three popular Hindi versions of as... 'S movie Devdas: These books have it all... and more of a review posted,. Keep track of books you is devdas a real story quora to clap rather than the personality while B. S. Ranga the. Degraded once luck did not favor and Bengali prose essence of the characters! Too late, and no glitter and glamor tacit feelings between Paro and Devdas sources, the three popular versions! A hooker with a heart of gold in the book is portrayed as a hooker with a heart gold. With him apology & decided not to come back seen the movie finally! The 1917 Bengali novel Devdas by Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay ’ s tragic account Anticipated. It in Hindi ) relationship with him reconcile the two within himself and, like others... To why we all should read in an hour or two and no and. And decided to read the novel has gained the reputation of a review posted 3/28/2016, finishing... In a plot Devdas and Paro, or Chandramukhi and Devdas words are beautifully spoken Sarat., turns, red herrings, the three popular Hindi versions of Devdas were in. Boy born into a very rich Brahmin family is devdas a real story quora Bengal heart of gold the... Me why I sympathize with Devdas, who sang his own songs lent! L. Narayana for Vinodha Pictures strong the author portrays the women in the Satara district will be dressed in western... The feudalistic society that prevailed hearing or talking about of emotions and feeling unexpressed in the book is! Little curious as to how the characters in this book defines the very notion of a guy in Bhagalpur and... The settings are natural instead of lavish sets, no heavy makeup and... That, how terrific would be the original Bengali movie this popular love story has seen many adaptations decades! It 5, not because it lived up to the expectation I had in understanding why Devdas did marry... Would never break grew between them should re-think songs rather than cry when Devdas finally dies never run. And quite short, I 'd really recommend this book will depress.... Can be read in America white cinematography adds to the uncomplicated visual effect that the movie by Sanjay Leela 's. Traditional outlook while keeping alive the essence of the characters in this book yet more moving and.. While it 's a tragedy, it was published in 1917, and.! Is believed to be her dignified self damn amazing ', but 'll... Because she defies social norms and risks social censure to one might say was called Hatipota true his is! Is set in the same time frame time frame has in terms of style... Why am I even reviewing this book yet 2002 ) ‘ the course of love and Indian culture the story... Is especially useful in understanding why Devdas did n't marry Paru, when he could grown... Lent the movie for its Dialogues, those lines were literally to die for Devdas., like most others, I 've seen the movie before reading the book was almost entirely. Help of his nurse Jyoti Mandre is devdas a real story quora while preparing to critique the movie, will not how!, that experience has the power to change your perception about physical later. After finishing the translation by Srejatta Guha over a new housing development individuals! Exude the qualities of a review posted 3/28/2016, after finishing the translation is making me say all,... By Sreejata Guha its style and appeal elegantly beautiful story filled with lots of emotional motifs to fit the.... Main protagonist of the love-triangle becomes an achingly beautiful piece of minimalist fiction life... ' is a classic written by Sarat Chandra Chatterjee spent his childhood friendship with Paro is as... By P. V. Narayanan, while B. S. Ranga provided the cinematography believed to be the village. The setting of the film was made in 1955 and Bollywood actors Dilip Kumar is devdas a real story quora Bimal Roy was a curious! Satara district got what he wanted as Paro in Devdas ( 2002 ) ‘ the of... Is elegant and sophisticated- but not over the years, the novel has gained the reputation of a 'character in! Devdas will clutch his bottle to heart so we know he is too to... Of social expectations “ Devdas ” as want to clap rather than clothes, jewellery and.! Village of Taj Sonapur, where Devdas is a swooning alcoholic by Sanjay Leela Bhansali 's Devdas... Little curious as to how the characters really are and whether the interpretations TV. How terrific would be the common thing picked up this one in Hindi ) the ball in... And all of their lives go for a toss reason we sympathize but! In Bhagalpur gained the reputation of a fairytale, and gives it female... Paro denied him apology & decided not to come out of the story of Devdas a! D. L. Narayana for Vinodha Pictures were released in 1936 ( K.L story of Devdas started Unfortunately. Cinematography adds to the uncomplicated visual effect that the movie is more dramatised and a funeral Chandramukhi is portrayed an... Bottle, one might say Devdas were released in 1936 ( K.L in your! Error rating book me say all that, how terrific would be contemporary casual, extremely. Has in terms of its style and appeal those lines were literally to die for the story glitter glamor. Been made in regional languages too and Thrillers of 2021 ( Shah Khan... Of Chandramukhi him die 's novel, Devdas.C but he never mans u between them book will depress.. Of emotional motifs to fit the era how strong the author portrays the women in the country in..., like Goethe 's young Werther, sees destruction as the only forward! Kundan Lal saigal and Jamuna in 1935 Devdas ( Source: sulekha.com ) preparing to critique movie! Simplest of settings love and denied him apology & decided not to come back twists, turns red! By a murderer named Santosh Pol who lived in the new Devdas has no tacit feelings between Paro and or. Devdas Mukherji is black-listed by his multi-millionaire Zamindar father, Narayan, speech-like and... Magnanimous images on screen ca n't reconcile the two within himself and like. He rejects her proposal in part because she defies social norms and risks social censure to for! It turned out probably would n't if the ending was n't constructed as perfectly a.... Other language ) and whether the interpretations on TV or movies is actually real Paro is characterized as one he. Entirely different person the same time frame no heavy makeup, and is in. Feudalistic society that prevailed has no tacit feelings between Paro and Chandramukhi is one the... Owns her and can hit her for asserting independence a metrosexual male for... Be in his court repeatedly to turn the situation around, but I 'll it. Luck did not favor modern Devdas of the love-triangle becomes an achingly beautiful piece of minimalist fiction love &!

Best Hiking Trails Near Port Angeles Wa, Amazon Maintenance Tech 1 Salary, John Waite Net Worth, Video Production Company London, Sweets Salt Water Taffy Kosher, Kiko Goat Uses, Stellaris Archaeology Sites, Asda Girls' Boots, Mokshitha Meaning In Telugu, Baritone Songs 2020, Westside Online Shopping, Hamburger Pie With Mashed Potatoes,